top of page

Chapter 25: The damaged roof structure.

...On a brisk morning in the Triad, Sherlock Holmes and Dr. John Watson found themselves on the roof of a quaint Victorian house, their inspector work taking priority today...

The duo, known for their astute investigative skills, also had licenses as general contractors, having built and inspected numerous houses over the years and that experience was being used today as they were entrusted with inspecting the roof structure of Mrs. Thompson's residence, a lady of means whose attic had caused her great concern.

"Ah, Watson," Holmes remarked as he surveyed the attic space, "the roof and attic reveal more than meets the eye. Observe the rafters; their arrangement suggests some modification."

"Indeed" Watson noticed some truss modifications near the skylight, an area that appeared to be susceptible to leaks. "It seems they attempted to address a previous issue, but their repairs might not have been sufficient," he commented, keenly observing the sagging rafters and roof sheathing nearby.

Holmes nodded, his piercing eyes darting across the attic. "Quite right, Watson. The sagging rafters and roof sheathing indicate possible structural damage, likely caused by inadequate ventilation."

"Ventilation, you say?" queried Watson, his curiosity piqued.

"Yes, Watson. Proper ventilation is essential to prevent condensation that could lead to water damage," Holmes explained. "Moreover, excessive heat build-up can warp and shrink wood, further contributing to the structural concerns we see here."

As they continued their inspection, the duo noted the absence of collar ties in some areas. "Ah, collar ties," remarked Watson, "I remember them well from our days as builders. They hold the rafters and help prevent rafter spread."

"Exactly, my dear Watson," replied Holmes. "In attics lacking collar ties, especially when the rafters run perpendicular to the joists, rafter spread becomes a likely issue, especially during heavy snowfalls."

Watson glanced at Holmes with admiration. "Your knowledge is truly unmatched, Holmes. But how do we address these concerns?"

Holmes donned a pensive expression. "The solution lies in reinforcing the roof structure, installing collar ties, and ensuring proper ventilation. These modifications will mitigate the risk of further damage."

They proceeded to inspect the rest of the attic, and their trained eyes spotted evidence of past fires, cracks in rafters, and areas where trusses were out of parallel. "These telltale signs reveal a history of troubles," Watson remarked, jotting down notes in his notebook.

"Indeed, Watson," Holmes said, pausing to assess the trusses carefully. "It appears someone attempted repairs by sistering the rafters, but the quality of the work is questionable."

As they descended from the attic, they met Mrs. Thompson, who awaited their assessment with anxious anticipation. Holmes, with his usual tact, began to explain their findings, guiding her through the issues they had observed.

"Madam," he began, "your attic requires urgent attention. The modifications and repairs performed in the past seem insufficient, and the lack of collar ties is exacerbating the rafter spread. Furthermore, inadequate ventilation has contributed to the sagging rafters and roof sheathing."

Watson added, "However, we believe that with the appropriate reinforcements and alterations, the structural integrity of your roof can be restored."

Mrs. Thompson looked at Holmes and Watson with gratitude and relief. "Thank you both for your honesty and expertise. Please, do what you must to ensure my home is safe and secure."

As they left Mrs. Thompson's residence, Watson marveled at their detective work's seamless integration with their knowledge as general contractors. "Holmes, it's remarkable how our diverse skills complement each other in such cases," he remarked.

Holmes nodded, a faint smile playing at the corners of his lips. "Indeed, Watson. The pursuit of knowledge in all domains enables us to unravel the most enigmatic of mysteries, even those hiding in the shadows of an attic."

Holmes and Watson know roof inspections
Holmes and Watson inspecting a roof

Cliff Notes:

Roof Structure and Attic:

- In an unfinished attic, the home inspector can see various structural framing elements, including rafters, trusses, joists, collar ties, and roof sheathing.

Collar Ties:

- Collar ties connect opposing rafters and are placed in the top third of the attic spaces.

- Collar ties hold the rafters down against the ridge board and help prevent rafter spread.

- Collar ties must be at least 1x4 (nominal) and spaced not more than 4 feet on center.

Finished Attics:

- Attics that have been finished into living spaces can pose significant problems.

- Floor joists in these cases may not be adequate to support a living space above.

Poor Ventilation:

- Proper ventilation is crucial to prevent condensation and structural water damage.

- It also helps prevent excessive heat build-up, which can warp and shrink wood.

- Insulation must be at least an inch away from sheathing and should not block vents.

Rafter Spread:

- A lack of rafter ties can cause rafter spread, particularly during heavy snows.

- Rafter spread often occurs near the middle of the ridge board, with outside walls keeping the ends of the ridge supported.

- This can cause ridge sagging and push the top parts of the walls out, especially during heavy snows.

Roof Leaks:

- When a roof leak is discovered, it's essential to determine the path of the water and assess any structural damage it may have caused.

19 views0 comments


bottom of page